When something is stuck inside · Updated November 2026
How to remove a toilet to get something out.
A toy, a toothbrush or a bottle cap wedged in the toilet's trap often cannot be pulled back up. It comes out from underneath, and that means lifting the toilet off the floor.
By Andrew HendersonRed Seal Plumber
Before you start
- Try an auger first. Something got flushed covers hooking it back out
- Buy a new wax seal and a set of closet bolts before you begin. The old seal cannot be reused
- A toilet is heavy and awkward, and the china breaks. Have a second person to lift
- If drain cleaner has gone in, stop here. Do not open a toilet with chemicals in it
What you need
- An adjustable wrench and a flat screwdriver
- A sponge, a bucket and old towels
- A putty knife
- Rubber gloves and eye protection
- A new wax seal and closet bolts
- A rag big enough to plug the drain opening
Taking it off
- Shut the water off at the valve behind the toilet, turning it clockwise.
- Flush and hold the handle down to empty the tank. Sponge out what is left in the tank and the bowl.
- Disconnect the supply line from the bottom of the tank. Have a towel under it.
- Pop the caps off the two bolts at the base and undo the nuts. If a nut only spins, hold the bolt with pliers.
- Cut the caulking around the base with the putty knife, if there is any.
- Rock the toilet gently to break the seal, then lift it straight up with two people. Set it on its side on towels.
- Plug the drain opening in the floor with the rag right away. It keeps sewer gas out and stops anything else falling in.
Getting the object out
Look into the outlet on the underside of the toilet. The object is usually sitting in the last bend, within reach of your fingers or a bent wire. If you cannot see it, run water from a bucket through the bowl over a tub or outside and watch what comes out.
If it is not in the toilet, it has gone into the drain in the floor. That is a job for a drain machine.
Putting it back
- Scrape all the old wax off the floor flange and the base of the toilet.
- Check the flange. If it is cracked, loose or sits below the finished floor, stop and call a plumber. A toilet set on a bad flange leaks.
- Fit the new bolts in the flange and press the new wax seal in place.
- Take the rag out of the drain.
- Lower the toilet straight down over the bolts. Press it down with your weight. Do not rock or twist it once it touches the wax.
- Tighten the two nuts a little at a time, side to side, until the toilet is firm. Stop there. Overtightening cracks the base.
- Reconnect the supply line, open the valve and let the tank fill.
- Flush several times and check around the base and the supply line for water.
Call a plumber if
- The shut-off valve will not close, or leaks when you turn it
- The bolts are rusted solid
- The floor around the toilet is soft or stained
- The flange is cracked or loose
- The toilet rocks after you have set it
- You find water at the base after a day
Questions
Can I reuse the wax ring after removing a toilet?
No. Once the seal has been compressed and broken it will not seal again. Fit a new one every time the toilet comes off the floor.
How do I know the object is still in the toilet?
If the toilet flushes weakly or blocks again and again after something went down, it is usually wedged in the trap. If it flushes normally, the object has most likely passed into the drain.
How long does it take to remove and reset a toilet?
For someone who has done it before, about an hour. Allow longer the first time, and have the new wax seal and bolts on hand before you start.
More toilet help
This page is general information, not professional advice for your situation. If you are unsure at any point, stop and call a licensed plumber. See the legal disclaimer.
